Sunday, September 1, 2013

Time to Find New Trading Partners

Rarely in professional sports do teams make trades with their division rivals.  The thought of giving a hated opponent something that they value is counter-intuitive to the thinking of a general manager.  Because each team faces their division rivals so many times during the season and will almost certainly have to face them in the playoffs, it is unwise to make any moves that would improve a division opponent.

There are exceptions to this rule.  On June 12, 2013 the Islanders traded impending free agent defenseman Mark Streit to Philadelphia for minor-leaguer Shane Harper and a fourth round draft pick.  Trades like these only happen in unusual circumstances.  In this case, Streit had publicly stated that he would pursue free agency.  Therefore, it made sense for Islanders GM Garth Snow to unload Streit to any team that would pay for him as opposed to letting him walk away in free agency, and getting nothing in return.

Over the past few years the Columbus Blue Jackets have made a lot of big trades.  They have made deals involving players like Jeff Carter, Rick Nash, Marian Gaborik, and Sergei Bobrovsky.  However, the divisional realignment could affect Columbus’ trading patterns.  Here is a list of all of the trades the Blue Jackets have made since June 15, 2012.
Date and Team
To CBJ:
To Other:
July 2, 2013 – TAM
Future Considerations
Rights to Drew Olsen (D)
June 30, 2013 – PIT
2013 2nd round pick
  2013 2nd round pick

2013 3rd round pick

April 3, 2013 – CGY
Blake Comeau (F)
2013 5th round pick
April 3, 2013 – NYR
Marian Gaborik (F)
Derrick Brassard (F)

Blake Parlett (D)
Derek Dorsett (F)

Steve Delisle (D)
  John Moore (D)


2014 6th round pick
April 3, 2013 – PHI
Michael Leighton (G)
Steve Mason (G)

2015 3rd round pick

April 3, 2013 – PIT
Patrick Killeen (G)
Future Considerations
March 12, 2013 – PHI
Matthew Ford (F)
Future Considerations
March 10, 2013 – WPG
Spencer Machacek (F)
Thomas Kubalik (F)
July 23, 2012 – NYR
Brandon Dubinsky (F)
Rick Nash (F)

Artem Anisimov (F)
Steve Delisle (D)

Tim Erixon (D)
  Conditional 2013 3rd round pick

2013 1st round pick

July 1, 2012 – OTT
Nick Foligno (F)
Marc Methot (D)
June 22, 2012
Sergei Bobrovsky (G)
2012 2nd round pick


  2012 4th round pick


2013 4th round pick
                                                                                                                       
                                                                                                                         
These trades show a trend in the Blue Jackets management.  Whether they were under Scott Howson (GM until February 2013) or under Jarmo Kekalainen (GM from February to the present), the Blue Jackets have traded heavily with former Atlantic Division teams.  Seven out of the eleven trades were to the Flyers, Rangers, or Penguins.  That is an astounding 64% of their trades.  Furthermore, three out of the four trades that the Blue Jackets made at the 2013 trade deadline, April 3rd, were to Atlantic Division teams.

None of the trades above were with the Blue Jackets former division rivals.  Columbus’ management wanted to ship their players to teams that they thought they would see only twice a year.  The realignment of the divisions moved the Blue Jackets to the Metropolitan Division, which consists of the five teams that were formerly a part of the Atlantic Division, the Carolina Hurricanes, and the Washington Capitals.  They will now have to face players who were once franchise cornerstones, like Rick Nash and Steve Mason, on a regular basis.  On the other hand, the Flyers will have to see Sergei Bobrovsky quite a bit and the Rangers will have to try to stop Marian Gaborik.


In the upcoming seasons it will be interesting to see who becomes trading partners with the Blue Jackets.  One thing is for certain, the CBJ-NYR and CBJ-PHI blockbusters that we have become accustomed to will have to cease.

No comments:

Post a Comment